Rubbing Salt in the Wound: Glowing Reviews on Stolen Art
This post dives into the unsettling reality of stolen designs selling online: customers leave glowing reviews, unaware the artwork was copied. It explores how positive feedback on knockoffs amplifies the impact of theft and why artists face not just loss of revenue, but also misattribution of their work.
Nathan Hadi
9/8/20251 min read
When searching for "chinoiserie pillow cover," there were 6 products at the top of the search results. All 6 were direct thefts of my mom's Redbubble designs that she wasn’t aware of.
To begin with, this is upsetting. However, when scrolling further down to see the reviews, there were hundreds of units sold.
"Absolutely Adorable. Love it!"
"High quality"
"If you like Staffordshire Dog Decor, this is a must! Super cute!"
Most people would have no idea that these products were ripped off. But to my mom, seeing her designs loved and purchased by hundreds of people, without any credit, is heartbreaking.
Ripped Off Reviews & Sales
On sites like Temu, the number of reviews and sales will increase your visibility. As every 5-star review increases your position in the search results. The more sales you have, the more popular you appear. Therefore, having hundreds of units sold increased the visibility of the stolen art.
Whilst the customer did appreciate the product, it wasn’t the correct person. The designs were very popular due to the positive reviews and high sales.
The True Cost
This is an issue for artists. While we may lose out on some revenue, it also means we have been removed from our story. We should be the ones receiving the praise from customers. Instead, the sellers are.
Why It Matters
This case study highlights how art theft online is not a hidden issue. It is in front of your eyes with 5 stars, customer images, and Verified Purchase.
It also shows how we need better protection. We shouldn’t have to watch strangers make money off our work. And customers should know their money is going to real creators. Not counterfeiters who are being given visibility.
Until this changes, we will always feel bittersweet at seeing positive reviews on counterfeit listings.
Join Us
Championing Creators’ Rights in the Digital Age
Get in touch
info@guardmyart.com
© 2025. All rights reserved.
